Orlando's Best NY Pizza [Updated 2024]

From the crispy thin crusts to the gooey melted cheese, I have tried and tested my way through 15 different pizza joints to bring you the top contenders. Being a proud Orlando native, I understand the importance of finding an authentic slice of New York right here in our city.

Whether you're a true New Yorker missing the taste of home or just a pizza lover in search of the perfect slice, this article is your ticket to pizza paradise. Get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey as I take you through the best ny pizza spots in Orlando, guaranteed to satisfy even the most discerning taste buds.

Tomasino's Pizza - Downtown Orlando

Highlights
Superb service
Delicious pizza
Best garlic knots
Reliable delivery
Fast delivery

Let me start by saying that the service at Tomasino's is nothing short of superb. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm smile and a friendly attitude. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, making me feel like a valued customer from start to finish.

And let's talk about the pizza. Delicious is an understatement. The crust was thin, crispy, and perfectly charred, just like a true New York slice should be. The sauce was flavorful and the cheese was melted to perfection. Every bite was a burst of flavor that transported me straight to the streets of Brooklyn.

But the real star of the show was the garlic knots. Oh my, the garlic knots at Tomasino's are hands down the best I've ever had. They were soft, buttery, and infused with just the right amount of garlic. Each bite was like a little piece of garlicy heaven.

And let's not forget about their reliable and fast delivery service. Whether you're craving a cheesy slice for lunch or a late-night snack after a night out, you can count on Tomasino's to deliver your pizza piping hot and in record time.

In conclusion, if you're looking for the best New York-style pizza in Orlando, look no further than Tomasino's Pizza - Downtown Orlando. Their superb service, delicious pizza, and mouthwatering garlic knots make them a standout in the city. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Orlando.

I Love NY Pizza & Subs

Highlights
Good food
Excellent pizza
Surprisingly good
Great service

Let me start by saying that I had quite a high expectation for this place, but I Love NY Pizza & Subs managed to exceed it with their good food and particularly their excellent pizza.

The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was hit by the aroma of freshly baked dough and savory toppings. With eager anticipation, I ordered a classic plain slice and a pepperoni slice. I can confidently say that both slices were a slice of heaven.

The first bite into the plain slice was like a burst of flavor in my mouth. The crust was thin and crispy, just the way a New York-style pizza should be. The sauce had a perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness, and the cheese was delightfully melted and gooey. It was a truly authentic ny pizza experience!

As for the pepperoni slice, it was a delightful surprise. The slices of pepperoni were generously scattered on top, adding a savory and slightly spicy kick to each bite. It was a heavenly combination that had me going back for more.

Aside from the surprisingly good pizza, I was also impressed by the great service I received. The staff was friendly and attentive, making sure that I had everything I needed to enjoy my meal.

In conclusion, I Love NY Pizza & Subs definitely stands out as one of the best options for ny pizza in Orlando. Their pizzas are excellent and their service is top-notch. If you're a pizza enthusiast like me, this is a place you won't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best buffet in Orlando.

NY Giant Pizza

Highlights
Amazing portions
Great quality
Accommodating hours
Hidden gem of a pizza place

Let me start by saying that NY Giant Pizza is a hidden gem of a pizza place in Orlando. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with the aroma of freshly-baked pizzas and the warm smiles of the staff.

This place is truly a haven for pizza lovers. The amazing portions they offer should not be taken lightly. Each slice is like a small feast, with generous toppings and a perfectly crispy crust. You won't leave here feeling hungry, that's for sure!

But it's not just about the quantity, it's also about the great quality of the pizzas. The cheese is rich and gooey, the sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the crust is just perfectly chewy. It's evident that they use top-notch ingredients in their pizzas.

One thing that sets NY Giant Pizza apart from the rest is their accommodating hours. Whether you're craving a late-night snack or an early morning meal, they've got you covered. They open early and close late, ensuring that you can satisfy your pizza cravings any time of the day.

In conclusion, if you're in Orlando and in search of the best NY-style pizza, NY Giant Pizza is a must-visit. It's a hidden gem that will leave you satisfied with their amazing portions, impressed by their great quality, and grateful for their accommodating hours. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Orlando.

I LOVE NY PIZZA

Highlights
Amazing customer service
Garlic knots perfection
Fresh ingredients
Good deals

From the moment I walked in, I was impressed by the amazing customer service at I LOVE NY PIZZA. The staff greeted me with warm smiles and were eager to assist with any questions I had. They made me feel like a valued customer right from the start.

Now let's talk about the star of the show: the pizza. I ordered their classic cheese pizza, and let me tell you, it was a slice of heaven. The crust was thin and crispy, just the way a New York-style pizza should be. The cheese was perfectly melted and had a wonderful stringy texture that made each bite truly satisfying.

But what really set this place apart were the garlic knots. Oh my goodness, these little bites of garlicy goodness were perfection. They were soft on the inside and had a slight crunch on the outside, just the way I like them. The garlic flavor was strong but not overpowering, and each knot was generously coated in melted butter and herbs.

One thing that I truly appreciated about I LOVE NY PIZZA was their dedication to using fresh ingredients. The sauce tasted vibrant and tangy, and the toppings were of the highest quality. I could tell that they take pride in sourcing the best ingredients for their pizzas.

Lastly, I have to mention the good deals they offer. Not only do they have affordable prices, but they also have weekly specials that make it even more tempting to indulge in their delicious pizzas.

Overall, I LOVE NY PIZZA in Orlando exceeded my expectations. With their amazing customer service, garlic knots perfection, fresh ingredients, and good deals, this place is a must-visit for any pizza lover in search of the best New York-style pizza in Orlando.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Orlando.

NYPD Pizza Metro West

Highlights
Excellent pizza
Good price
Friendly staff
Cozy atmosphere

Let me start by saying that this place definitely knows how to make a fantastic pizza. From the first bite, I could tell that their dough is made with love and passion, creating a thin yet perfectly chewy crust that's reminiscent of the authentic New York style.

Not only does NYPD Pizza Metro West excel in taste, but they also provide an outstanding value for your money. The prices are more than reasonable, especially considering the generous toppings they pile onto each pizza. It's a deal you don't want to miss!

The friendly staff at this joint deserves a special mention. They greet you with warm smiles and are always ready to help recommend the best slices for your preference. Their knowledge about pizza is impressive, and it's evident that they take pride in their work.

The cozy atmosphere at NYPD Pizza Metro West adds an extra layer of enjoyment to your dining experience. You can choose to dine-in and relax in their comfortable seating area or opt for takeout if you're in a hurry. Either way, the ambiance is inviting and perfect for enjoying a great slice of pizza.

To sum it up, if you're craving an excellent ny pizza in Orlando, look no further than NYPD Pizza Metro West. With their delicious offerings, friendly service, and cozy atmosphere, you'll be transported straight to the streets of New York City with each and every bite.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Orland Park.

New York Pizza and Burgers

Highlights
AWESOME
PERFECT
GREAT food, service
New favorite spot

Let me start off by saying, this place is AWESOME! From the moment I stepped foot inside, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, enticing my taste buds.

The first thing that caught my eye was the perfect crust. It had just the right amount of chewiness and crispiness, giving it that classic New York pizza texture. Every bite was a delight, with the flavors blending together harmoniously. The tangy tomato sauce, the gooey cheese, and the generous toppings all worked together to create a PERFECT slice of pizza.

Not only was the food outstanding, but the service also surpassed my expectations. The staff was friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about their offerings. They were more than happy to answer any questions I had and even recommended some of their specialty pizzas.

New York Pizza and Burgers has quickly become my new favorite spot for pizza in Orlando. The combination of the GREAT food and exceptional service makes it a must-visit for any pizza lover. Whether you're craving a classic cheese slice or feeling adventurous with toppings, this place has it all.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best ny pizza in Orlando, make sure to swing by New York Pizza and Burgers. You won't be disappointed. Trust me, this place deserves all the accolades it receives.

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Orlando.

Broadway New York Pizza

Highlights
SO GOOD AND ON POINT
Closest taste to NY pizza
Open until 3 am
Authentic Italian pizza
Great prices and service

Let me start by saying, this place is so good and on point when it comes to serving top-notch New York-style pizza. Just one bite and I was transported back to the bustling streets of the Big Apple.

What impressed me the most about Broadway New York Pizza was its close resemblance to the authentic taste of NY pizza. The thin and chewy crust, the gooey cheese, and the perfectly balanced sauce created a symphony of flavors that would make any New Yorker proud.

But the goodness doesn't stop there. One of the advantages of Broadway Pizza is that it stays open until 3 am. That means you can satisfy your late-night cravings with a slice of heaven whenever you please.

The pizza here is as authentic as it gets. I could almost envision myself sitting in a traditional Italian pizzeria, surrounded by the aroma of freshly baked dough and the passionate shouts of the chef. It's truly an experience worth savoring.

What's even better? The prices are incredibly reasonable for the quality you receive. Combine that with the friendly and efficient service, and you have a winning combination that keeps customers coming back for more.

In conclusion, if you're in Orlando and craving a taste of genuine NY pizza, Broadway New York Pizza should be at the top of your list. Don't miss out on this slice of deliciousness!

You might also want to check out the best pho in Orlando.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

Highlights
Nice and helpful staff
Tasty and reasonably priced
Better than New York pizza
Family friendly atmosphere

First and foremost, the staff at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay was simply fantastic. They were incredibly nice and helpful, making me feel right at home the moment I walked through the door. They were more than happy to assist me in selecting the perfect slice of pizza for my taste buds.

Speaking of taste buds, let me tell you, the pizza at NYPD Pizza Lake Cay is out of this world. It's tasty and packed with flavors that will leave you wanting more. And the best part? It's reasonably priced! You get top-quality pizza without breaking the bank.

Now, I know what you're thinking. How can pizza in Orlando be better than New York pizza? Well, my friend, let me tell you that NYPD Pizza Lake Cay has managed to capture the essence of New York pizza and bring it right to your taste buds. The thin, crispy crust and the perfect blend of cheese and sauce will transport you straight to the streets of the Big Apple.

But what sets this place apart even further is the family-friendly atmosphere. Whether you're dining with your loved ones or grabbing a quick bite on your own, the warm and welcoming ambiance of NYPD Pizza Lake Cay will make you feel like you're part of their family.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best ny pizza in Orlando, look no further than NYPD Pizza Lake Cay. With their nice and helpful staff, tasty and reasonably priced slices, and that unmistakable New York flavor, this place truly deserves a spot on your pizza bucket list.

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Orlando.

Lazy Moon Pizza

Highlights
Huge slices
Fairly priced
Plenty of seating
Friendly staff
Cheesy bread

When it comes to pizza slices, size does matter, and Lazy Moon Pizza definitely delivers in that department. The slices at this place are huge! Trust me, you won't leave hungry here. Plus, they are fairly priced, so you're getting a lot of bang for your buck.

One thing I really appreciated about Lazy Moon Pizza is their ample seating. They have plenty of space available, so you don't have to worry about finding a place to sit and enjoy your delicious pizza. Whether you're dining with friends or looking for some alone time with your slice, you'll be able to find a cozy spot.

The friendly staff also adds a delightful touch to the overall experience. They are always ready to guide you through the menu and offer recommendations based on your preferences. Their warmth and enthusiasm truly enhance the dining experience.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza itself. Lazy Moon Pizza serves up an authentic taste of New York with their thin crust and generous toppings. The cheese is wonderfully melted and the sauce has the perfect balance of tanginess and sweetness. And if you're a fan of bread, make sure you try their cheesy bread – it's a heavenly complement to the already amazing pizza.

In conclusion, Lazy Moon Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Orlando. With its huge slices, fair prices, ample seating, friendly staff, and of course, their mouthwatering cheesy bread, it offers an unforgettable slice of the New York pizza experience right here in the heart of Orlando.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Orlando.

Gitto's Pizza

Highlights
Amazing food
Friendly staff
Home-y atmosphere
Quick service
Cool looking venue

From the moment I walked into Gitto's Pizza, I knew I was in for a treat. The home-y atmosphere instantly made me feel welcomed and comfortable. The venue itself was cool, with its unique decor and cozy seating arrangements.

But let's move on to the most important part - the food. And boy, was it amazing! The first bite into their New York-style pizza was like a flavor explosion in my mouth. The crust was perfectly thin and crispy, just the way it should be. The sauce had a tangy and rich flavor that complemented the cheese and toppings perfectly. Each slice was a work of art, with the precise distribution of ingredients and the ultimate cheesy stretch.

Not only was the food fantastic, but the staff at Gitto's Pizza were also incredibly friendly. They were attentive and enthusiastic, and their knowledge of the menu was impressive. They seemed genuinely passionate about their pizza, which added to the overall enjoyment of the experience.

What really impressed me was the quick service. Despite it being a busy night, my pizza arrived promptly, hot and fresh from the oven. It was evident that the team at Gitto's Pizza takes pride in their efficiency and attention to detail.

If you're on the hunt for the best New York-style pizza in Orlando, Gitto's Pizza is a must-visit. With its amazing food, friendly staff, and home-y atmosphere, it will surely tick all the boxes for pizza enthusiasts like myself.

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Orlando.

Pizza@LakeEola

Highlights
Fast lunch with great prices
Mind blowing pizza options
Huge brownies for a snack
Friendly staff

Let me start by saying that if you're looking for a fast and affordable lunch option in Orlando, Pizza@LakeEola is the place to go. With their great prices, you won't have to break the bank to enjoy a delicious slice of NY-style pizza.

Now, let's move on to the star of the show: the pizza. Oh boy, let me tell you, the options here are mind-blowing. From classic favorites like margherita and pepperoni to unique creations like buffalo chicken and BBQ pulled pork, there's something to satisfy every pizza lover's cravings. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, just like a true NY pizza should be, and the toppings are always generous. Each bite is a heavenly experience that will transport you straight to the streets of the Big Apple.

But wait, there's more! Pizza@LakeEola also offers a selection of huge brownies that are the perfect sweet treat for a post-pizza snack. Trust me, you won't want to miss out on these indulgent delights.

Not only is the food top-notch, but the friendly staff adds to the overall enjoyable experience. They are always ready to welcome you with a smile and provide excellent service.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the best NY pizza in Orlando, look no further than Pizza@LakeEola. With their delicious options, fast service, and friendly atmosphere, this place truly stands out. Make sure to visit and satisfy your pizza cravings, because life's too short for anything less than a phenomenal slice.

1803 Pizza / Kitchen

Highlights
Warmth and flavor
Incredible taste
Genuine hospitality
Fantastic desserts
Clean and great service

From the moment I stepped into 1803 Pizza / Kitchen, I was enveloped in a sense of warmth and flavor. The scent of freshly baked dough and tangy tomato sauce filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation. I knew I was in for a treat.

The pizza at 1803 Pizza / Kitchen exceeded all of my expectations. Each bite was a flavor explosion, with the perfect balance of tangy sauce, gooey cheese, and a thin, crispy crust. It was clear that every ingredient was of the highest quality, resulting in an incredible taste that transported me straight to the streets of New York.

But it wasn't just the pizza that impressed me. The staff at 1803 Pizza / Kitchen showed genuine hospitality, making me feel like a valued guest as soon as I entered the establishment. They were attentive, knowledgeable about their menu, and made excellent recommendations.

To my delight, 1803 Pizza / Kitchen also offers a selection of fantastic desserts. I couldn't resist trying their homemade cannoli, and let me tell you, it was worth every calorie. The creamy ricotta filling paired perfectly with the crisp, flaky shell, leaving me craving more.

The cleanliness of the restaurant and the great service rounded out my experience at 1803 Pizza / Kitchen. The tables were spotless, and the staff was diligent in ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable dining atmosphere.

If you're on the hunt for the best NY pizza in Orlando, look no further than 1803 Pizza / Kitchen. With its warmth, incredible taste, genuine hospitality, fantastic desserts, and clean and great service, it's a must-visit for any pizza lover in the city.

Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Hot and Fresh
Thin crust
Mom and pop owned and operated
Consistent, friendly, fast
Not a chain and priced well

Let me start by saying, if you're craving an authentic New York slice in Orlando, look no further than Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant. This hidden gem is truly a delight for pizza enthusiasts like myself.

As soon as I stepped into the restaurant, I could feel the warmth and friendliness that only a mom and pop owned and operated establishment can offer. The aroma of hot and fresh pizzas filled the air, making my mouth water in anticipation.

What sets Pizzeria Del-Dio apart from the competition is its commitment to a thin crust. Every delicious pie I tried had the perfect balance of crunchiness and chewiness - just the way a true New York pizza should be. The toppings were incredibly flavorful, and the cheese melted to perfection.

One thing I appreciated about Pizzeria Del-Dio is its consistency. Every time I visited, I knew I could count on friendly staff and a fast, efficient service. None of that generic, impersonal experience you might find in chain restaurants.

Speaking of which, Pizzeria Del-Dio is a mom and pop shop through and through, not a faceless chain. And priced well. I found their prices to be more than fair for the quality and quantity they provide.

In conclusion, if you're seeking the best ny pizza in Orlando, Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant should be on your must-visit list. Their dedication to a thin crust, hot and fresh pies, and friendly service make them a standout in the city's pizza scene. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

John & John’s - A Pizza Shop

Highlights
Best pizza in Florida
Caring and attentive employees
Delicious NY style pizza
Flavorful pepperonis
Great service and atmosphere

Let me start by saying, wow! This place truly deserves all the praise it receives. Without a doubt, John & John’s offers the best pizza in Florida. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by friendly and caring employees who were eager to make my dining experience enjoyable.

Now, onto the star of the show – the pizza itself. I ordered a classic NY style pizza and I must say, it was nothing short of delicious. The crust had the perfect balance of crispy and chewy, and the cheese was oozing with flavor. But what really stood out were the flavorful pepperonis, which added an extra kick to every bite. It was like a flavor explosion in my mouth!

I also want to commend the staff for their impeccable service. Not only were they attentive, but they genuinely seemed to enjoy what they were doing. It was evident that they took pride in their work, and this positive energy translated into a fantastic dining atmosphere.

As I sat there, savoring each mouthwatering slice of pizza, I couldn't help but feel like I was transported to the bustling streets of New York. John & John’s truly captures the essence of authentic NY pizza, bringing it right here to Orlando.

In conclusion, if you're on the hunt for the ultimate NY pizza experience in Orlando, look no further than John & John’s - A Pizza Shop. Trust me, you won't be disappointed.

A Slice Of NY Pizza

Highlights
Great food
Fresh and tasty
Friendly owners
Highly recommended

A Slice Of NY Pizza in Orlando is truly a gem in the city's pizza scene. From the moment I stepped inside, the smell of fresh dough and melted cheese wafted through the air, instantly igniting my appetite and excitement.

The great food at A Slice Of NY Pizza surpassed all my expectations. The slices were generous in size, with a perfect ratio of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Each bite was an explosion of flavors that transported me straight to the bustling streets of New York City. The crust had a satisfying chewiness, and its thinness allowed the toppings to shine through. It was evident that only the freshest ingredients were used, as the vegetables were crisp and bursting with flavor.

What sets A Slice Of NY Pizza apart is not only their exceptional food but also the genuine warmth of the owners. Their passion for pizza is palpable, and they take the time to engage with their customers, making you feel like part of their family. Their friendly nature and dedication to customer satisfaction truly enhanced the overall dining experience.

It's no surprise that A Slice Of NY Pizza comes highly recommended in the quest for the best ny pizza in Orlando. The combination of great food, freshness, and the personal touch of the owners makes it a standout in the city. Whether you're a local or a visitor, be sure to indulge in a slice or two. Your taste buds will thank you, and you'll find yourself coming back for more.