Orlando's Best New York Style Pizza [Updated 2024]

In my quest to find the most delicious slice in town, I have meticulously visited and reviewed a staggering 15 pizzerias throughout Orlando. Trust me, I take my pizza seriously.

And now, I am ready to unveil the crème de la crème of the New York-style pizza scene in the heart of the Sunshine State. Brace yourself for an extraordinary culinary journey filled with mouthwatering slices of cheesy goodness, perfectly thin and crispy crusts, and delectable toppings that will transport you straight to the streets of the Big Apple.

So, grab a napkin, prepare your taste buds, and let's embark on this savory adventure together!

Tomasino's Pizza - Downtown Orlando

Highlights
Superb service
Crunchy and gooey pizza
Best garlic knots

Let me just start by saying, wow! Tomasino's Pizza truly blew me away with their superb service and mouthwatering pizza.

From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a friendly smile and welcoming staff who made me feel right at home. Not only were they attentive and knowledgeable, but they also went above and beyond to ensure that my dining experience was top-notch.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: their pizza. Every single bite was a delightful symphony of flavors and textures. The crust was perfectly thin and crunchy, providing the ideal foundation for the gooey and cheesy goodness on top. It was the kind of pizza that makes you close your eyes and savor every moment, completely lost in the bliss of each bite.

Oh, and let's not forget about the garlic knots. These little bundles of joy were the perfect complement to the pizza. Warm, soft, and seasoned to perfection, they had just the right amount of garlic. Each bite left me longing for more.

Overall, my experience at Tomasino's Pizza was nothing short of extraordinary. The combination of their superb service, crunchy and gooey pizza, and the best garlic knots made for an unforgettable dining experience. If you're in Orlando and in search of the best New York style pizza, Tomasino's Pizza is an absolute must-visit.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Orlando.

Napoli Italian Pizzeria

Highlights
Friendly staff
Amazing food
Clean restaurant
Great atmosphere
Homemade jalapeño poppers

Let me start by saying, "Wowza!" Napoli Italian Pizzeria truly exceeded my expectations in every aspect. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the most friendly staff I've encountered in any pizzeria. Their warm welcome made me feel right at home.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza! Napoli Italian Pizzeria serves up some amazing food that rivals the best of New York. The crust was thin, yet delightfully chewy, just like it should be. The sauce was tangy and flavorful, and the toppings were fresh and abundant. Every bite was a taste of pizza perfection.

Not only was the food outstanding, but the restaurant itself was spotless. It's clear that Napoli takes pride in maintaining a clean restaurant for its customers. The modern and cozy ambiance added to the overall experience, creating a great atmosphere for enjoying a slice of heaven.

Before I forget, I must mention the homemade jalapeño poppers. They were a spicy and cheesy delight that perfectly complemented the pizza. Don't skip out on these tasty treats!

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Orlando in search of the best New York style pizza, look no further than Napoli Italian Pizzeria. With their friendly staff, amazing food, clean restaurant, great atmosphere, and mouthwatering jalapeño poppers, it's a pizza lover's paradise. Napoli is truly deserving of a place on any list of the best new york style pizza in Orlando.

You might also want to check out the best buffet in Orlando.

NYPD Pizza Metro West

Highlights
Excellent pizza
Perfectly crispy
Delightful tang
Fresh and abundant
Friendly staff

Walking into NYPD Pizza Metro West, I was immediately drawn in by the excellent pizza aroma wafting through the air. As a connoisseur of new york style pizza, I was thrilled to see the large selection of pies on display.

I eagerly ordered a classic cheese slice, and as I took my first bite, I was met with a satisfying crunch. The crust was perfectly crispy, giving just the right amount of resistance to my teeth. It was clear that NYPD Pizza Metro West takes pride in their dough-making technique.

What truly impressed me was the delightful tang of the tomato sauce. It had a subtle hint of sweetness balanced with a gentle acidity that danced on my taste buds. It was a flavor profile that transported me straight to the streets of New York.

I also appreciated the fresh and abundant toppings that adorned the pizza. The cheese stretched just the right amount as I took each bite, and the generous portions of pepperoni were evenly distributed, ensuring every bite was packed with flavor.

To top it all off, the staff at NYPD Pizza Metro West were incredibly friendly and welcoming. They took the time to answer my questions and provided excellent service throughout my visit.

Overall, I must say that NYPD Pizza Metro West is a strong contender for the title of best new york style pizza in Orlando. The combination of excellent pizza, perfectly crispy crust, delightful tang, fresh toppings, and friendly staff make this pizzeria a must-visit for any pizza lover in the area.

You might also want to check out the best steak in Orlando.

I Love NY Pizza & Subs

Highlights
Good food and service
Excellent pizza
Surprisingly delicious

Let me start by saying that I was pleasantly surprised by the excellent pizza at I Love NY Pizza & Subs. As soon as I entered the restaurant, the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough filled the air, setting my expectations high.

The good food and service truly impressed me. The staff was friendly and attentive, eager to ensure that I had an enjoyable dining experience. They were knowledgeable about the menu and took the time to answer any questions I had.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the pizza. The crust was perfect; thin, yet sturdy enough to hold all the flavorful toppings. The cheese was perfectly melted and provided a delightful stringy texture with every bite. The sauce had a harmonious balance of tanginess and sweetness, making it a standout feature of the pizza.

One bite into the pizza and I immediately knew that this was something special. Each ingredient complemented the others, creating a symphony of flavors. The combination of the fresh toppings with the perfectly baked crust was truly a match made in pizza heaven.

Overall, I must say that I Love NY Pizza & Subs offers a surprisingly delicious new york style pizza. It's a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking an authentic slice of New York in Orlando. With its good food, friendly service, and of course, the excellent pizza, this place undoubtedly deserves a spot on the list of the best new york style pizza joints in Orlando.

You might also want to check out the best lunch in Orlando.

Lazy Moon Pizza

Highlights
Huge slices
Fairly priced
Plenty of seating
Friendly staff
Vegan and vegetarian options

Let me start off by saying that Lazy Moon Pizza truly lives up to its reputation as a slice of New York in Orlando. As soon as I entered the bustling pizzeria, I was greeted by the aroma of freshly baked dough and a lively atmosphere.

One of the highlights of Lazy Moon Pizza is their slices, and when I say slices, I mean huge slices. These generously sized pieces of pizza were a sight to behold, and they certainly did not disappoint in taste either. Each bite was a mouthwatering combination of crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and gooey cheese.

What pleasantly surprised me even more was the affordable prices. In a city like Orlando, it's not always easy to find a delicious slice of New York style pizza that won't break the bank. However, at Lazy Moon Pizza, you can savor their delectable slices without emptying your wallet – a win-win!

Finding a seat was a breeze at Lazy Moon Pizza, thanks to their ample seating areas. Whether you prefer a cozy spot by the window or a lively spot near the bustling pizza ovens, there's a seat for everyone.

The staff members at Lazy Moon Pizza were not only efficient but also exceptionally friendly. They made me feel welcome and were more than happy to answer any questions I had about their pizzas and even offered suggestions for toppings.

Another standout feature of Lazy Moon Pizza is their dedication to catering to different dietary needs. They offer a variety of vegan and vegetarian options, ensuring that everyone can enjoy a slice of their delicious New York style pizza.

In conclusion, if you're searching for the best New York style pizza in Orlando, look no further than Lazy Moon Pizza. With their huge slices, affordable prices, plenty of seating, friendly staff, and options for vegans and vegetarians, Lazy Moon Pizza is a slice above the rest.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Orland Park.

Broadway New York Pizza

Highlights
Tucked away location
Authentic NY pizza taste
Open until 3 am
Affordable prices
Great service

Let me start by saying that Broadway New York Pizza is truly a hidden gem. Tucked away in a cozy corner of Orlando, this place offers an authentic taste of New York in the heart of Florida.

From the moment I stepped inside the pizzeria, I knew I was in for a treat. The aroma of freshly baked pizza greeted me, and I could immediately tell that the ingredients were of the highest quality. The crust was thin and crispy, just like a classic New York slice should be, and the toppings were plentiful and flavorful. I savored every bite, impressed by the effort put into creating an authentic taste.

Another aspect that sets Broadway New York Pizza apart is its incredible hours. Whether you're craving a late-night snack or an early morning feast, this place has got you covered. With a closing time of 3 am, you can satisfy your pizza cravings any time of the day or night.

What impressed me even more was the affordability of Broadway New York Pizza. In a city often associated with high prices, this place offers delicious slices at a reasonable cost. It's the perfect spot to grab a quick bite without breaking the bank.

Lastly, I must mention the exceptional service I received. The staff at Broadway New York Pizza were friendly, attentive, and passionate about their craft. They were happy to answer any questions I had about their pizzas and even gave me recommendations for other local spots to try.

In conclusion, Broadway New York Pizza is a must-visit for anyone searching for the best New York style pizza in Orlando. Its tucked away location, authentic taste, late-night hours, affordable prices, and great service make it a standout among its competitors. Trust me, once you take a bite of their pizza, you'll understand why Broadway New York Pizza deserves a spot on the top of your pizza bucket list.

You might also want to check out the best ramen in Orlando.

NY Giant Pizza

Highlights
Amazing portions
Great quality
Hidden gem

NY Giant Pizza in Orlando is truly a hidden gem when it comes to finding the best New York style pizza in the city. From the moment I walked into the restaurant, I could tell that this place takes their pizza seriously.

One of the highlights of NY Giant Pizza is their amazing portions. I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw the size of their slices – they were truly giant! Each slice was larger than my hand, and I found myself struggling to finish just one. But let me tell you, it was worth every bite!

Not only were the portions impressive, but the quality of the pizza was outstanding. The crust was perfect – thin and crispy, just like a true New York slice. The cheese was melted to perfection, and the tomato sauce had a hint of sweetness that balanced the flavors beautifully.

What sets NY Giant Pizza apart from the competition is their attention to detail and commitment to using fresh ingredients. Every bite was bursting with flavor, proving that their pizza is made with care and passion.

Overall, I highly recommend NY Giant Pizza for anyone in search of the best New York style pizza in Orlando. Its amazing portions, great quality, and hidden gem status make it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best pho in Orlando.

Gitto's Pizza

Highlights
Tasty and filling pizza
Friendly staff
Home-y atmosphere
Quick service
Cool venue

I walked into Gitto's Pizza feeling hungry and eager to taste their renowned New York-style pies. The atmosphere instantly transported me to a cozy neighborhood pizzeria in the heart of the Big Apple. The home-y ambience was warm and inviting, the kind that makes you want to linger and savor each delightful bite.

As I placed my order, the friendly staff greeted me with genuine smiles, making me feel like a regular customer. You could tell they were passionate about their craft. And speaking of craft, the pizza at Gitto's was nothing short of exceptional. The crust had just the right amount of chewiness, and the toppings were generous and flavorful.

I opted for the classic combination of pepperoni and mushrooms. The first bite was an explosion of savory goodness, with the slightly charred edges adding a satisfying crunch. Each subsequent bite only reaffirmed my initial impression—Gitto's certainly knows how to make a tasty and filling pizza.

One thing that stood out about Gitto's was their quick service. Despite the steady stream of customers, I never had to wait long for my order. It was clear that efficiency was a priority for them, a trait that is highly appreciated when I'm in dire need of a pizza fix.

Finally, let's not forget to mention the venue itself. The cool and contemporary design added a touch of sophistication to the overall experience. It's a place where you can enjoy your pizza and have a fun night out with friends or family.

In conclusion, Gitto's Pizza truly impressed me with their delectable New York-style pizza, friendly staff, home-y atmosphere, quick service, and cool venue. If you're in Orlando and craving an authentic slice of the Big Apple, give Gitto's Pizza a visit. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Orlando.

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay

Highlights
Friendly service
Reasonable prices
Delicious toppings
Family-friendly atmosphere

NYPD Pizza Lake Cay is a hidden gem when it comes to New York-style pizza in Orlando. Upon entering the pizzeria, I was immediately greeted by friendly and attentive staff who made me feel right at home. The friendly service added a personal touch to my dining experience, making me feel like a valued customer.

One of the things that truly stood out about NYPD Pizza Lake Cay was the reasonable prices. As an expert on pizza, I understand the importance of getting great value for your money, and this place did not disappoint. I was pleasantly surprised by the affordable prices, especially considering the generous portion sizes and high-quality ingredients.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show – the delicious toppings. NYPD Pizza Lake Cay offers a wide variety of toppings to suit any taste bud. From classic pepperoni to unique combinations like prosciutto and arugula, their menu is a pizza lover's dream come true. Each bite was a burst of flavor, and the freshness of the ingredients truly shined through.

Not only did NYPD Pizza Lake Cay impress me with their pizza, but their family-friendly atmosphere made it a place where everyone can enjoy a good slice. The cozy and inviting ambiance, paired with the friendly staff, made it the perfect spot for a casual family outing or a relaxed dinner with friends.

In my quest to find the best New York-style pizza in Orlando, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay definitely stood out from the crowd. With their friendly service, reasonable prices, delicious toppings, and family-friendly atmosphere, it's a place that I would highly recommend to any pizza enthusiast looking for an authentic and satisfying slice.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Orlando.

Pizza Xtreme

Highlights
Extremely nice
Traditional menu
Fast and friendly
Crispy crust
Pleasant experience

First and foremost, the staff at Pizza Xtreme were extremely nice and welcoming. From the moment I walked in, I felt right at home. They were more than happy to answer all my questions and help me navigate their traditional menu.

The service was fast and friendly which is always a plus when you're hungry and craving a slice of authentic New York style pizza. Speaking of pizza, the one thing that stood out to me the most at Pizza Xtreme was their crispy crust. It had the perfect level of crunch without being too hard or overdone.

I ordered a classic cheese pizza, and it did not disappoint. The cheese was gooey and melted to perfection, and the tomato sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. The combination of flavors was truly delightful.

What was also impressive about Pizza Xtreme was the overall experience. The atmosphere was pleasant, and the restaurant had a cozy and inviting vibe. It's the kind of place where you can enjoy your pizza in peace or strike up a conversation with the friendly staff.

In conclusion, Pizza Xtreme in Orlando is definitely a must-visit for any pizza lover searching for the best New York style pizza. With their extremely nice staff, traditional menu, fast and friendly service, crispy crust, and pleasant experience, I can confidently say that they are a top contender in the quest for the perfect slice of pizza in Orlando.

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Orlando.

Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant

Highlights
Hot and Fresh
Thin crust
Mom and pop owned
Consistent
Friendly

From the moment I stepped into Pizzeria Del-Dio, I could tell this was a mom and pop owned establishment that takes pride in their food. The aroma of fresh, hot pizza wafted through the air, immediately making my mouth water.

I wasted no time ordering their classic new york style pizza and eagerly awaited its arrival. When it finally appeared before me, I was delighted to see a thin crust that looked perfectly crispy and golden. The cheese was generously spread, and the toppings were fresh and vibrant.

As I took my first bite, I was met with a burst of flavor that instantly transported me to the streets of New York. The combination of the tangy tomato sauce, gooey cheese, and savory toppings was simply divine. Each bite was an explosion of taste, and the airiness of the crust added a delightful crunch.

What impressed me the most about Pizzeria Del-Dio was the consistency in the quality of their pizza. It's clear that they take great care in selecting only the finest ingredients and making each pizza with precision.

Not only was the pizza outstanding, but the staff was incredibly friendly and welcoming. They truly made me feel like part of their pizza-loving family.

In conclusion, Pizzeria Del-Dio Italian Restaurant in Orlando is a shining gem when it comes to finding the best new york style pizza. With their hot and fresh pies, thin crust, and unbeatable taste, this place is a must-visit for any pizza aficionado.

I LOVE NY PIZZA

Highlights
Garlic flavor wings
Amazing customer service
Fresh ingredients
Good deals
Crispy wings

Let me start by saying that I was blown away by the flavors at I LOVE NY PIZZA. As a connoisseur of new york style pizza, I always look for that perfect combination of a crisp yet chewy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese. And boy, did I find it here!

What impressed me the most was the attention to detail in their ingredients. Each slice was topped with fresh ingredients that were bursting with flavor. The sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, and the cheese was perfectly melted and gooey. Every bite was a heavenly experience.

Now, let's talk about the wings. Oh boy, those garlic flavor wings were something else! The meat was tender and juicy, and the garlic flavor was just right - not overpowering, but enough to give it that extra kick. It's safe to say that I devoured them within minutes.

Apart from the mouthwatering food, the customer service at I LOVE NY PIZZA was top-notch. The friendly staff went out of their way to ensure that my dining experience was nothing short of exceptional.

And to top it all off, they had some great deals on their menu. Who doesn't love a good deal, right?

In conclusion, if you're in search of the best new york style pizza in Orlando, look no further than I LOVE NY PIZZA. Their fresh ingredients, crispy crust, and amazing customer service make it an absolute standout. I'll definitely be returning for more of their delectable pizzas!

John & John’s - A Pizza Shop

Highlights
Best pizza in Florida
Caring employees
Flavorful pepperonis
Great service

Let me begin by saying that this pizza joint unquestionably serves the best pizza in Florida. As soon as I walked through the door, I was enveloped by the aromatic scent of freshly baked pizza, transporting me straight to the streets of New York.

What makes John & John’s truly exceptional is their caring employees. From the warm smiles to their attentive service, they go above and beyond to ensure their customers have a fantastic dining experience. It was evident that they are genuinely passionate about their craft.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza! I ordered their classic cheese and pepperoni pizza, and boy, was it a flavor explosion! The crust was thin and crispy, just like a true New York slice, providing the perfect vehicle for the flavorful pepperonis. The balance of tangy marinara sauce, gooey mozzarella, and generous toppings created a delightful harmony of flavors. Each bite was a nostalgia-inducing journey that transported me back to the streets of Brooklyn.

Furthermore, the service at John & John’s was top-notch. The staff was knowledgeable about their menu and offered great recommendations. They swiftly brought out my piping hot pizza, and continued to check on me throughout my meal to ensure everything was to my liking.

In conclusion, John & John’s - A Pizza Shop offers an exceptional New York style pizza experience right here in Orlando. With their delicious, authentic pies and caring employees, it's no wonder they rank among the best in the city. If you're looking for a slice that will transport you to the streets of the Big Apple, don't miss out on John & John’s - it truly lives up to the New York pizza legacy.

Planet Pizza Orlando

Highlights
Good service
Interesting
Variety of pizzas

Let's start with the service. I have to say, the staff at Planet Pizza Orlando is top-notch. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with smiles and a warm welcome. The service was prompt and attentive throughout my visit, making me feel like a valued customer.

Now, let's talk about the pizzas. Oh boy, they are interesting. Planet Pizza Orlando offers a wide variety of toppings and flavor combinations that will leave you intrigued and excited to try something new. Whether you're a traditional cheese lover or enjoy more adventurous toppings, they have you covered.

But what really caught my attention was the crust. The thin and crispy crust at Planet Pizza Orlando is the epitome of authentic New York style. It had that perfect combination of chewiness and crunch that I look for in a good slice. And let's not forget about the generous amount of cheese and the flavorful sauce that adorned the pizza. Every bite was a delicious explosion of flavors.

In conclusion, Planet Pizza Orlando is a must-visit for any pizza lover searching for the best New York style pizza in Orlando. With their good service, interesting flavor combinations, and variety of pizzas, you won't be disappointed. So, do yourself a favor and head over to Planet Pizza Orlando to indulge in a slice of culinary delight. You won't regret it.

Ziggie's Pizza

Highlights
Delicious pizza
Cozy bar atmosphere
Unique and delicious taste
Friendly and attentive staff
Wide variety of pizza combinations

Ziggie's Pizza in Orlando is a delightful gem that should not be missed by any pizza enthusiast. As soon as I walked in, the cozy bar atmosphere embraced me, making me feel right at home.

The pizza at Ziggie's is absolutely delicious. From the first bite, I could taste the expertise of the chefs in each slice. The crust was thin and perfectly crispy, just like a true New York-style pizza should be. But what truly set Ziggie's apart from other pizzerias was the unique and delicious taste of their pizza. The sauce had just the right amount of tanginess, and the cheese was perfectly melted and flavorful.

Not only was the pizza amazing, but the staff at Ziggie's were also impressive. The friendly and attentive staff made me feel like a valued customer from the moment I walked in. They were knowledgeable about all the different pizza combinations they offered and were quick to make recommendations based on my preferences.

Speaking of pizza combinations, Ziggie's boasts a wide variety of toppings and flavor profiles to choose from. Whether you're a classic cheese lover or someone who enjoys more adventurous combinations, Ziggie's has something for everyone. Their menu truly caters to every pizza lover's cravings.

In conclusion, Ziggie's Pizza in Orlando is a must-visit for anyone searching for the best New York-style pizza. Their delicious, unique, and flavorful pies, combined with a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, make for an unforgettable dining experience. Don't miss out on the chance to try this hidden gem in the heart of Orlando.